What do a publication founded by Gen X bloggers and a YouTube channel started by Gen Z high schoolers have in common? More than you would expect!
Episode chapters
- 00:00 | Intro
- 04:59 | The art of collaborating
- 09:58 | The Twin Cities video
- 16:43 | Overlap with college studies
- 20:28 | Our broken political decision making
- 29:26 | Avoiding burnout
- 38:18 | Ensuring longevity
- 46:32 | Minnesota’s hunger for urbanist content
- 51:50 | Sparking joy
- 56:30 | Outro
Links
- House of Transit’s video: The Transit System the Twin Cities Deserve
- An Oral History of Streets.mn
- Map Men
- History of the Orange Line from Scott Dibble & Frank Hornstein
- House of Transit’s Skokie Swift video
- Banks Rail
Attributions
Our theme song is Tanz den Dobberstein, and our interstitial song is Puck’s Blues. Both tracks used by permission of their creator, Erik Brandt. Find out more about his band, The Urban Hillbilly Quartet, on their website.
This episode was produced and edited by Parker Seaman aka Strongthany with editing assistance and transcription by Ian R Buck. Many thanks to Emmett and Evan for coming on the show! We’re always looking to feature new voices on the show, so if you have ideas for future episodes, drop us a line at [email protected].
Transcript
[00:00:02] Ian: Welcome to the Streets.mn Podcast, the show where we highlight how transportation and land use can make our communities better places. Coming to you from an Amtrak train, precise location unknown, I am your host, Ian R. Buck. Today we have another episode of For Fun and for Profit, the series where producer Parker Seaman invites urbanist content creators to talk about their process. We’ll be chatting with Emmett and Evan from the House of Transit, who recently published a video essay about what an ideal transit system would look like in the Twin Cities, and they were gracious enough to cross-publish it on Streets.mn. Let’s jump in.
[00:00:40] Parker: All right, we have in the house with us tonight, House of Transit. Do you two want to introduce yourselves? Tell us a little bit about yourselves and a little bit about your channel.
[00:00:51] Emmett: Yeah, so I’m Emmett. I’m a civil engineering student at Northwestern, obviously really passionate about transit. And Evan and I met online, so I’ll let him introduce himself and we can talk a little more about the channel.
[00:01:05] Evan: Hi, I’m Evan. I go to DePaul University and I’m a geography major. And I also have long had a passion for like urbanism and then kind of transportation, you know, since like, I don’t know, high school or something, long time.
[00:01:22] Emmett: Yeah, so back in high school, we were in some shared Discord servers, actually. It’s where all the great connections begin. RM Transit coming out of COVID was a really big channel. So we were in that server and eventually we spun off and created our own thing. And along with a bunch of other people kind of around our age who are interested in transit, we decided to create a YouTube channel called the House of Transit. So that was really the inspiration for it. It’s a group channel in the sense that we have a lot of different people who can contribute and upload videos. I would say Evan and I are really the backbone of the channel. We’ve really put in the most hours, the most work to it, but it’s kind of cool because I don’t think there’s a lot of channels out there where it’s just like a big group effort and anybody who wants to create something, post whatever they want.
[00:02:07] Evan: We have projects like in the works right now with like people who just came into our Discord servers like, “hello, I want to do a project on like such stuff.” And it’s like, whoa, that’s kind of crazy. And we can like incorporate them because we’re like all about like anyone can kind of make a project with us because we’re supposed to be like a big kind of collaboration of people. So I think that’s what makes our channel kind of cool and unique from others.
[00:02:29] Parker: That is that is really cool. I think the only other one I could think of that kind of operates in a similar sort of fashion is Streets.mn where it’s a community blog. And if you want to contribute, you can you can email [[email protected]].
[00:02:40] Ian: One thing that I was surprised by when I saw your guys’ stuff and obviously found the YouTube channel first. Well, Parker just literally sent me a link to your episode about the Twin Cities and said, “I want to have these guys on the podcast. And I was like, I want to have these guys on our YouTube channel.” So that’s why I reached out to you to, you know, mark it as a collaboration on YouTube. And but then but then I was clicking around in the about section and I was like, “oh, they have they have just a website. They have like a blog.” And I was really surprised because you guys are in college right now. And like, I feel like Gen Z doesn’t think about blogs. Correct me if I’m wrong. But that you know, that’s like an early 2000s kind of format.
[00:03:20] Evan: I think we’re all different. When I was like, a freshman in high school, I remember reading urbanist blogs for Greater Greater Washington. You’ve ever heard about them?
[00:03:31] Ian: Yeah, yeah, actually, Streets.mn was was modeled after Greater Greater Washington.
[00:03:35] Evan: Yeah, that’s like a classic one right there. I’ve read a lot of stuff. And I was like reading it like daily when I go to class and like not pay attention to what’s going on.
[00:03:45] Emmett: Yeah, I’m I’m from the other Washington. I’m from Seattle. And I definitely I think we were all sort of coming up with our own ideas, just finding ways to talk about transit in any way we could in high school. And I did do a guest article for the Urbanist out in Seattle. And I enjoyed that. But I think I YouTube just definitely enables you to reach a much bigger audience. So it’s like beach have their place. I think for people who are really curious and want to get into the weeds about specific topics, blogging is great. And YouTube just makes it a lot more accessible to a lot of people.
[00:04:20] Evan: Yeah, you could go into in depth on blogging in a way you can’t really get into on like YouTube. And then also, there’s like the talking factor as well, like a blog post, depending on like how much you’re trying to put into it can be a lot simpler to write out than like, I have to write a script, I have to think about filming locations, who’s doing what, where do we want to go? Where do we need to go? And then after all the recording is done, oh, now I got to edit it all. It’s like a lot more concise, and I can put like, more interesting ideas that I don’t think the YouTube audience would really like as much in the blog. So I think it’s like a it’s a nice balance between the two.
[00:04:53] Ian: Nice.
[00:04:59] Ian: I noticed that so you said that you two met in a Discord server. And you were on was that when you were in high school, you were on opposite ends of, you know, West Coast, East Coast. And then you both ended up in Chicago at universities in Chicago. Was that coincidence? Or did you guys? Were you guys like, “hey, like, we want to be able to like hang out in person, let’s try and find some, some schools in Chicago- in the same place.”
[00:05:23] Emmett: Yeah, that was that was total coincidence. We had met up for like five minutes before where I’ve been doing a camp out in DC, like an architecture class. And I swung by and we met up on the metro for five minutes. And that was the only time we’ve met in person before. But yeah, it was pure coincidence that we both ended up in Chicago. And around that time, I’ve been watching a lot. I don’t know if you all are familiar with Jay Foreman? But they have Mapmen, which is this they basically they go into a series called unfinished London, where they just talk about all these different infrastructure projects in London or other things they’re interested in. And it’s really goofy, like British humor, where they’ll just have all these like random little bits that they’re doing. But yeah, it’s the two of them who are sort of talking in the studio, and then they’ll go out to in person stuff. And I was like, “wow, I think I think we could pull off something like that,” you know, and so that was the first time that we really even collaborated on anything. It wasn’t until we got to Chicago that we were like, oh, yeah, we can we have these shared interests, we can try to make videos together.
[00:06:21] Evan: Yeah, because initially, both of our videos were like very centric on Seattle for you Emmett and like DC for me. I did stuff about Washington metro expansion. And then also when Potomac Yard opened up, I did a video about that. And then you’ve done stuff about the, you know, rapid expansion of link and our first video was Northgate, right? Yeah. So when we came to Chicago, we were able to make like, the new genre of like Jay Foreman inspired stuff. And that’s what we’ve been working on with like, most stuff based in Chicago. So we have like the BRT one, which was our very first one. Not a lot of people watched that. But we also collaborate with a friend of ours, Aaron, who’s based out in the Bay Area with that as well. Talking about like different kinds of BRT and like what works best, depending on like the context and such and like talking about Pulse, which is something happening in Chicago suburbs. And then our second video in this style was like the Chicago L video, which was one that really like took off compared to the rest. Like that one was I think the first like bigger one before because that was the first bigger one after like Boston, I guess.
[00:07:23] Parker: Because the one before that has 500 some views and then your Chicago L one has 22k.
[00:07:29] Emmett: Yeah. Yeah. It was that was really I think the cool thing about starting this channel, too, is when you’re small, you can just do a lot of experimentation of changing up the styles. So that was one where we really leaned into the humor aspect and just trying to make it like we don’t get too technical. It’s just like really approachable. And I think we saw that people really like that.
[00:07:47] Parker: Yeah, no, I can I can definitely see that because I was doing my research last night. And by that, I totally mean like looking up stuff about you guys and not staying up till one in the morning watching YouTube videos. But the Chicago L one, now that you’ve mentioned that you really like Jay Foreman and Map Men, I completely see it. The videos have been mainly made by you two and there is a very strong style that comes through it. How do you to break down like sharing the work that you do on that? Like how does script writing go? How does editing and producing and all that sort of stuff go? Because you seem to be very in line with the sort of stuff. I don’t get the sense that one part was made by one of you. One part was made by another.
[00:08:25] Evan: It really depends on the video or the subject matter. But usually we’ll have like both of us working like at least some part of the video with each other. So like for the Chicago L, we both kind of like helped write the script. Emmett started it and then I helped like look over it. And then filming was handled by both of us, obviously, because they’re both in the video. But I was the one with the camera and Emmett had the mic. And then Emmett does usually does the editing. I edit some of my own videos for like the DC ones. But usually Emmett handles all the editing. And in the case of like the Twin Cities one, the script was written basically all by Emmett. I didn’t really have much to say. But I was there for the recording when we went to the Twin Cities like two summers ago and was able to talk about it like on camera and then also brought my own camera. So even if we’re not like writing the script, even if like one of us isn’t writing the script necessarily, we’ll still like collaborate on stuff like filming and such.
[00:09:18] Emmett: Yeah, I’m glad that it seems fluid and connected because it can be kind of like a group project situation. If you do this, I do that. And we, you know, piece it all together. But if it’s done convincingly, that’s a success in my book. For some context for me of how I sort of got into video editing, I had a YouTube channel in high school, totally different. I call it Random Content Generator. And it’s just like making like random comedy edits and stuff. So completely different. But I think it’s it helped with like the zany aspect of pulling in and doing weird things and seeing what you can do with YouTube that like other people aren’t doing.
[00:09:58] Parker: Going back to the Twin Cities video, like Ian mentioned, that was kind of what pulled me into wanting to have a conversation with you guys because I thought that video was excellent. It like mixing together the concept of how transit could be expanded here, what makes it good, what makes it like how it could be better. And then further going into detail about how it could be really expanded out to create a modal shift and providing reasoning for all the different sorts of ways. Like it doesn’t get into the nitty gritty of the infrastructure, but it gets into it enough to show here’s how the ways that it could be expanded and why those would work. So walk me through a bit of the process of like working on that sort of balance in the context of that video.
[00:10:43] Emmett: Yeah, so these we have a few of these videos where sort of like fantasy map expansion sort of thing. And we were, I think both of us were sort of making these maps for cities around the country before we were on YouTube and YouTube sort of became a way to like present that. And so a lot of them, it’s like the map came first. We had these ideas of things that should happen. And then, you know, we go in, create the video, talk about the city. I think this is the first one where we’re sort of inverting it. And I think this is something we’ll do from now on of like really digging into what’s the history of the Twin Cities themselves, what are things they need. And I think the audience really likes to have this sort of clear cut vision as just something tangible of like, oh, wow, imagine if that was real. And there’s some of that for sure. But obviously, you know, with YouTube, there’s only so much flexibility you can have and we’re going to acknowledge like it’s not really like this is the vision for the Twin Cities. This is just something that we think could be great, hopefully a way to start the discussion at least. So, yeah, there was a lot of really thinking about what’s what’s been lacking. We both we went to Minnesota a couple of years ago, as Evan mentioned. And so we were around just filming things we got to understand the system firsthand. And then I’ve also been following along between CityNerd and then also the I-94 Rail Coalition that we mentioned this whole obviously I-94 is really a very destructive freeway in the project that MnDOT has been doing is, you know, unlike anything else that the country is really doing for something at that scale. So I think it was a really cool opportunity to unpack this particular region, of course, but also kind of to have broader lessons for the country as a whole, because there’s a lot of issues that the Twin Cities are facing that really, if they can figure them out, that’s so important for the country as a whole.
[00:12:25] Evan: I just feel like the Twin Cities are a great example of a very median American city. Sometimes they have a decent light rail system that’s pretty good. It has some problems, but by and large, services the region pretty well. Mixed with a very slow bus system that they’re working to speed up. But obviously you have to consider regional demand as well. So it’s nice to bring in more high profile projects like I-94 rail that can help fill in that gap of higher speed region serving rail service that could bring it all together.
[00:13:00] Ian: So speaking of that regional demand, I was really impressed in the video of most of the lines that you proposed are things that I’m like, “oh, yeah, as a local, I probably would have come to that same conclusion.” But I wouldn’t expect out of towners to look at a map and immediately be like, yeah, yeah, yeah. We should connect these three places together. So what’s your process for planning out the fantasy map? Or are you looking at population density kind of heat maps? Or what’s?
[00:13:33] Emmett: Yeah, there’s Christoph Spieler is a pretty big person in the industry. He’s got this book called Trains, Busses, People, and it’s a really great book, if any of you are familiar with it. But it outlines like sort of just generally what does transit need? First thing he explains basically is you’ve got your population centers, you’ve got your job centers. How do you connect those two? So I think that is a huge part of what we’re looking at is just like population density, obviously uptown super high density area, a lot of jobs there too. And it’s just not really well connected. So that’s got to be something that gets prioritized. I will say he sort of provides us with a little in because this book does go through and sort of analyzes all of these metro areas. So that’s that’s how I first learned about, for example, the Southwest Corridor and how that was South West LRT, how that was initially supposed to go through these really dense areas of Minneapolis and then ended up totally missing that. So, yeah, there’s a lot of research. But I think I think it’s easy to make something that looks like you know what you’re talking about. I’m going to say because I think because it really like population jobs like really are the biggest part, right? Like if you can just connect those two things, that’s what transit needs to do. But I think there’s that extra like five or 10 percent that we are maybe missing. And I think it’s a fine line of, you know, being able to identify things that hopefully like, you know, I’m thrilled that you agree with the corridors that we’ve selected, but also not wanting to, you know, miss out on anything that like really only a local would be able to understand about travel patterns and about what people need and what can and can’t work.
[00:15:12] Ian: Sure. Yeah, OK. Actually, now that you’re saying that, you know, I guess the state fair, like that particular location at that particular time of year is probably something that, you know, a local would be able to be like, “yeah, we need lots and lots of lines right there.” But that’s only applicable for two weeks.
[00:15:30] Parker: But by the two weeks, it is.
[00:15:33] Emmett: I think we saw someone in the comments mention that too on the video. So great minds think alike.
[00:15:39] Ian: One thing one thing that I did see a lot of locals responding with was if you ever want to know how to pronounce a particular town’s name, you can just ask us. From now on, every time that I think of Owatonna, I am going to think “Owatonna Wapapata.”
[00:15:58] Emmett: Yeah, I across every video, this is always the biggest thing in Boston and the Boston video we made, I intentionally mispronounced Worcester, and I’m still getting comments like four years later, but it’s not “Warchester.” What are you saying? And stuff like that. So that’s and I get it because I mean, I would be doing the same thing if anybody in Seattle mispronounced anything. Yeah, no, it’s a it’s an endless source of entertainment for me.
[00:16:32] Ian: It did give the transcription software a heck of a time.
[00:16:43] Parker: You two are both going to school for majors that I would say either highly or at least indirectly relate to urbanism and the stuff that you’re passionate about, but you both kind of picked different angles to go about that. Tell me a bit more about like why you picked the majors that you do and how you kind of see that relate to that.
[00:17:04] Evan: For me, I remember right before, like right when I was getting my first year accepted into DePaul, I was set to do public policy as a major. And then last minute, I switched it to geography because I was in a GIS class doing stuff with like Arc GIS. And for me, that was like really interesting like work right there, like analyzing, you know, geospatal trends and stuff like that. And that’s how I like really like to approach a lot of like analysis about metro areas and such. Like, I remember when I was reading Greater Greater Washington, lots of like maps and such being published on the website, showcasing like, here’s the population density of the D.C. area from like 1970 until like 2017 or thereabouts. And then all kinds of maps. And I’m like, this is very fascinating way to like look at transit because obviously where things like jobs are, where people are, as Emmett said earlier, are like the foundation of a lot of transit planning. You know, those are the things you’ve got to connect at the end of the day. And so like knowing where certain jobs are clustered versus where like people live in high densities and where like, you know, people have different incomes or different like social backgrounds, like where they work, depending on like what jobs they’re working, are all many things you can like consider and think about when you’re thinking about like potential ridership, which for like transit expansion or stuff like that. It’s a very like interesting angle to come at like transit expansion with when you’re thinking like, OK, where? Just like the general question of where.
[00:18:37] Emmett: Yeah, no, I definitely would second that. I think maps are essential to this industry and there’s just such a great way to communicate so much. For me, coming into college, it was really going to be between urban planning and civil engineering. Those were kind of to me like two angles to get at transportation. I’m actually more interested in the planning side, so I think it’s been interesting to go the other route and go more technical. I was definitely nudged that way by my father. Also, there’s the fact that Northwestern doesn’t have urban planning at all and they just lost their geography department. So interestingly, sort of this trend of like the technical, I think, is getting a lot more attention where it doesn’t really need it. But the cool thing about that at Northwestern actually is that because we don’t have these other things, a lot of the social science aspect gets pulled into the civil department. So I’m currently in a civil engineering class. I mean, I mean, the only three transportation classes offered for undergrads at Northwestern right now. One of them is an econ class. One of them is your traditional traffic, the highway capacity, whatever you got to understand the enemy to defeat them, right? And then the third one is kind of this complete streets take on things, which I think, based on what I’ve heard from other civil engineers, is not something you’d normally expect to find in a civil department. But it’s really cool because there’s this emphasis not only on data modeling, regression, all that good stuff, but also just the social science aspect of talking to people, understanding the problem. And I think that’s something that’s missing in a lot of these departments. So, yeah, it’s it’s hard because I think what a lot of people think civil engineer, they don’t really think someone who is engaging with the public. But that’s definitely the lens that I’m the most interested in. And fortunately, that’s something that I’ve been able to learn during my four years here.
[00:20:28] Ian: You said that it’s easy to make a map that looks like you know what you’re doing, like plan out a route that makes sense, which makes me really sad that so often like our our big capital improvement transit projects end up being things that like just don’t make sense. And it’s like, like, what what is broken about our decision making process that leads, you know, like elected officials to select a route that’s like like who who put the Bassett Creek light rail station here? It’s in the middle of a field. There’s nothing there.
[00:21:06] Emmett: Yeah, I mean, the the frustrating answer that I think we all can think of is politics. I don’t know the political situation in the Twin Cities specifically to be able to talk about this, but I think a great example would be the Red Line, which cost it was somewhere in like 500 million dollars or something runs every 20 minutes. Actually, that cost figure might not be right. I think it was used by 500 people a day. And so that makes it pretty hard to justify. Why is this like a big colorful line on our map?
[00:21:34] Ian: Right.
[00:21:34] Emmett: And we’re not investing in the most central parts of the city. And so I think, you know, without being familiar, so you guys can correct me if I’m wrong here. But I think if when you have a Metropolitan Council that represents the entire region, everybody wants something right. And so you really need to spread that around. And when you have, you know, easy right of way that’s cheap and you can just throw something out there and who cares if it’s successful, because it’s really not that big of a deal versus the political fight that it takes to put rail right in these super dense neighborhoods where there’s so many more people there, so much more benefit, but so much more cost associated with that, too. We end up, unfortunately, as a country, just trending towards the former and not really trying to pursue these projects that have huge benefit, but we’re scared away by the costs.
[00:22:22] Ian: And the Red Line has another fun layer on top of it, which is that it goes from Metro Transit’s service area into the Minnesota Valley Transit Authority’s service area. So there has been like fights back and forth about who should be operating this line and who’s going to collect like the revenue from it. So it’s that’s that’s been a fun a fun angle as well.
[00:22:48] Evan: Yeah, unfortunately, so many agencies can like just get into petty squabbles and stuff over like the most minor details when it comes to like, you know, revenues, who’s going to like operate what? Like it’s unfortunate, like reality of like a lot of agencies. So they kind of have like like this kind of tunnel vision about like what needs to happen. And it’s like only me only I have to benefit. And everyone else is like not necessarily an equal party. You know, like I have to maximize my benefits for my operating agency and everyone else can help sometimes if they’re like willing to. But like that’s like that’s the view of such suspicion often. So it’s like an unfortunate reality. Also, if I remember correctly, I’m not I’m not the local Twin Cities local, but also you guys have a fairly like decentralized structure when it comes to like choosing projects, because it’s a lot of like all the local jurisdictions and stuff submit like what they want. And then like it’s up to Metro Council to decide what’s get funding and what doesn’t get funding, right?
[00:23:49] Ian: Yeah. And that’s so so for like large transit projects, it’s almost always the counties that bring those that that do the initial planning for the route and everything. And then it gets handed off to Metro Transit to actually implement. And that’s that’s when it goes from having like a code name to having an actual color, you know, designation on the map. But yeah, you’re right. That like even, you know, all kinds of like bike bike lane projects, you know, like all kinds of things get get funneled through the Met Council, you know, because they are whatever the whatever the federal structure, you know, mandated, every metro area has to have whatever the entity is that like the federal government gives them money and then they decide like where it goes. And for us, that’s the Met Council. So everybody’s trying to, yeah, compete for putting together a pretty presentation about, you know, well, we want to we want to put, you know, a nice separated bike lane in downtown Saint Paul. And why is that going to why should that be prioritized over something in a different part of the metro area?
[00:24:55] Evan: Yeah, it’s interesting because it’s like you guys are basing a lot of this on like cash instead of like agencies, because like here in Chicago, we obviously have Metra, CTA and Pace who for for a while before the recent legislation that got passed last year, were also kind of like doing the same kind of like vying for funding stuff and having to deal with like maybe like lots of billions of dollars of our federal dollars go to the CTA projects while, you know, capital projects for Metra and Pace got like the scraps. But for you guys, it’s like, oh, if I want to build like a new transit line, it’s like Hennepin County, I guess, has to plan out what it’s going to be. And then they have to like hope that this gets support. And even though Hennepin County is like the one with like all the people living in it because it has Minneapolis, it’s like you can only have so much because everyone else is also proposing their own projects, be it like a very suburban county proposing the Red Line or a very urban county like Hennepin.
[00:25:52] Ian: Right. Yeah, yeah. And I mean, to be fair, all of the major, like the big capital improvement projects that I can think of with regards to transit have been in Hennepin County or Ramsey County.
[00:26:05] Parker: Yeah.
[00:26:05] Ian: And that’s like the only game in town. I think the Red Line kind of came about as part of like to to sweeten the pot for a highway expansion project. So, you know, that went well.
[00:26:21] Emmett: Yeah. Yeah, too often we hear that story around.
[00:26:25] Evan: Is that the same reason the Orange Line exists?
[00:26:28] Ian: Sort of. So folks can go back and listen to the interview that I did with Scott Dibble and Frank Hornstein, who were, you know, our state senator and state house representative from the Uptown area, who like they got their start in this space as transit advocates in like the 90s. And and they told me about the fight that they had to prevent 35W from getting expanded. Many, many, many years later, we ended up getting the Orange Line. And it’s kind of a, you know, half-baked version of what it could have been 20 years ago.
[00:27:10] Parker: Which is really sad because the Orange Line is nice. I like the Orange Line. But what if it like but what if it was what it was supposed to be?
[00:27:16] Ian: Right. Right.
[00:27:17] Emmett: Seattle always comes up as the example of in the 70s. They voted on a essentially what would have been the third on top of WMATA and BART, D.C. Metro and Bay Area Rapid Transit, the third great post-war metro. They voted it down. And then that money went to Atlanta. Seattle’s now trying to rebuild the system that they could have had 60 years ago and which would have been even more comprehensive.
[00:27:44] Ian: On the subject of having multiple different like agencies all, you know, with their own little fiefdoms, I have I have an idea that I’ve had for a while and I want to pitch you guys on it. I want I want to create like a an alternative rule set for Ticket to Ride, because whenever I play Ticket to Ride, I’m always looking at the networks that end up getting created. And I’m like, “this would suck as a passenger. This would be the worst rider experience ever.” And and I would love to make a board game where it’s like everybody’s competing with each other to try to, you know, whatever the goal set is, like I need to get my network to be the best one. But also, if you stab everybody else in the back too much, like if the collective score reaches a certain threshold, you know, then then everybody loses. So there can only be one winner, but there could be none.
[00:28:42] Emmett: I like this. Yeah, I think it’s like a deceptively simple game. And I think I feel like that would add definitely a layer of complexity, either if it was like you all earn points from connecting or you’ll lose points from, yeah, failing. I think that would be pretty fun.
[00:28:59] Evan: Yeah, definitely a way to like make it more interesting. You know, you have to keep in mind how other people are doing. You can’t just be like, I’m actually take this route instead myself. You have to be like, OK, maybe you can have this route. I have to take a slightly different way.
[00:29:13] Emmett: I think we need a lot of transit executives across the country to play this game whenever you produce it.
[00:29:19] Parker: I think they could just ride the bus for once.
[00:29:26] Parker: How do you two avoid getting burnt out on spending this much time working on this sort of stuff? Like, obviously, you’re passionate about it and you’re making videos on it and you have a blog on it and you’re going to school. Feels like it’s, from my perspective, something you think about day in and day out. So have you ever had to, you know, take care of yourself in those sort of considerations when doing this sort of work and advocating for this sort of stuff? How do you how do you kind of balance doing all this sort of stuff with, you know, not not ruining it for yourself?
[00:30:00] Emmett: Yeah, I mean, I think ultimately school comes first, right? And so we are we’re definitely limited in that capacity. It’s definitely I would say it actually oscillates quite a bit where some some weeks, some months, like I’m thinking about YouTube every chance I can, like any any free time, however rare it is. I come by that. I’m trying to get some editing in, work on a script, whatever I can. And other times it just it has to go kind of to the side. You know, I don’t think about it as much. I think in some ways that actually prevents burnout because I feel very fortunate when I’m able to work on these projects to be able to do that. And also, I would say that it’s it’s separate enough for at least like historically has been from what I’m doing in school or internships, whatever, that it’s really like, yeah, it doesn’t feel like it’s conflicting with that. I can see that changing, you know, if I if you end up working full time somewhere 40 hours a week and then you’re going home and talking about it feels like the same things. But I think for now that really, you know, there’s there’s enough scarcity of it as not having YouTube be like a full time job or anything like that, that really it’s remained a passion project and something that I really love doing. I think individual projects can drag on for a long time. So you worry about losing the motivation that initially led to you choosing a topic. But but no, there’s always more to talk about. I’m like my biggest problem is having too many ideas. And I feel like most YouTubers would say the same thing.
[00:31:32] Evan: Yeah, I have a lot of projects that I started and have not finished. And also, I agree with the idea that like this being a passion project is better. If I had to do this full time, I feel like I get to like burn out very easily because it’s just like I have to keep thinking of ideas whereas instead it’s like one inspiration. When it strikes, it’ll come to me and I can like work on something. And I think it’s better when you have that like inspiration come to you instead of having to like figure it out when you need it, because it’s like I could think about something that might be more unique than if I’m just like trying to force something out. You know, I might come up with a video idea that I wasn’t even really thinking about. But now, like I was just like going down some kind of like silly little Wikipedia or like blog rabbit hole and now like, wait, I should do a video about this. And that’s completely out of left field. Like one video I thought was really fun. It’s one of my favorites is the Skokie Swift video where I wrote about like the history of the Skokie Swift and kind of talked about the history of transit planning in America. And what really inspired that video was just like going through this website called ChicagoL.org and looking at all the like old stations that used to be on the line, the history of the line, like all the context around it, like when it got brought back. And like, wow, this is like fascinating stuff. I would have never thought we should make a video on this. And then I was like, wait, this would be a great video, though. And for me, it’s one of my favorite videos, definitely my favorite one that I’ve written. And I think it’s a it’s a great watch.
[00:33:00] Emmett: Yeah, the flip side of that is that sometimes inspiration will strike in the unlikeliest places and I’ll just be like up at 2 a.m. and I cannot sleep because every time I try to sleep, I have new thoughts about this video idea that just popped into my head. And so it’s me like flip flopping between opening up Google Docs on my phone, typing a few more sentences, putting it away. I’m like, all right, it’s time to sleep. And then no, no, no, we got it. We have to write more. We got to think about this. So it’s it’s hard when when you get the creative juices flowing, it’s hard to push them aside.
[00:33:32] Evan: But the nice thing is, though, is like because we’re like pretty good friends, we can just like shoot ideas at each other sometimes and like concepts and stuff. So even if it’s like even if we’re not going to end up making a video on it, it might get like reappropriated into another video. So like sending over like script work and progresses or just like communicating about like I think about how about this kind of like concept? You know, it’s a great way to like share ideas and knowledge with each other and coming up with, I think, like really strong like thoughts and concepts that we can then transport over into our videos.
[00:34:07] Ian: So what’s your… Pick one like long term thing that’s been on the back burner for a while. Like like what’s your white whale? That you haven’t gotten to yet.
[00:34:17] Evan: For me, one video that just will sometimes reappear to my mind, I get so much inspiration is a video about Miami. Now, Emmett mentioned earlier about the like three great postwar metros, San Francisco, D.C. and Atlanta. But there was supposed to be like a fourth and fifth. And I think people kind of know about like what Baltimore was supposed to be and then didn’t become. I feel like that’s pretty like common knowledge that got shared across the Internet over the years. But Miami to me is a really fascinating case because they were supposed to have a very extensive system and all they ended up getting was like one line that got slowly expanded. And part of what makes it so interesting is like looking into like, OK, how does transit expansion go wrong? So I ended up going into a lot of like old news articles from back in the day, taking advantage of my student like access to these kind of databases and looking at stuff about like the Miami Metro construction and such. It’s a very fascinating topic that every once in a while would just appear right back in my head. I’m like, I need to I need to write more about Miami and then it just goes away. It’s like suck. It’s like stuck in like purgatory right now or every once in a while I’ll be like, I need to focus on this. And then I just like I just lose track of it and get distracted by other stuff, unfortunately.
[00:35:31] Ian: It would be a good excuse to go and visit Miami, too. You know, you got to you got to get some of that B-roll.
[00:35:36] Emmett: Yeah, and go see Yana Santentacumpo playing over the Heat now. Yeah, you all might find this amusing, actually. But the Minneapolis video kind of was my white whale for a while there. I was working on that the original map and like soliciting feedback from people on our server probably like two, two and a half years ago even. And then I took the Empire Builder for the first time across the country from Seattle to Chicago to get out here for college, stopped in the Twin Cities for a couple of days, got some B-roll, thought that would be enough. A year later, Evan and I went out there again, collected more footage, filmed all the in-person stuff, which is now a year old. And then finally this year, I was like, all right. Like, it’s not that I lost passion for the project. I think it was just like there wasn’t really like one thing. Sometimes like when a new new project opens or whatever, it’s like, all right, we got to get this out now. But that that moment had kind of been lost. And I realized that I had like so many other things I was trying to do. I was like, all right, Minneapolis needs to happen. And, you know, I’m thrilled that it really took off in the way that it did compared to the videos that we’ve put out before. I think now what maybe pushed that video to get done is I’ve always been really interested in Canada. Canada is just such an interesting place. I really I never thought about it in the transit context until Reese Martin came out and just like made transit YouTube in general really big. But obviously, really talking about that. And it’s just so weird because it’s like their built form is in some ways so similar to the US, but their transit ridership just far exceeds us, of course. So it’s just it’s really interesting as like, you know, this is attainable. We’re not talking about Paris. We’re not talking about Tokyo. We’re just talking about Vancouver, which quietly has arguably the best transit system in North America. And so I’ve been really wanting to do a lot of comparison videos actually between different city pairs. But we were at the end of the summer. We were out in the Pacific Northwest. And I was showing Evan around my homeland. But we went to Portland and Vancouver, which are two cities that really have a lot in common in terms of parallel histories. And but so different in terms of the success of their transit systems and just what quality of life is like there now. So I think it’d be really interesting to kind of unpack that. Just what is the US doing that’s great? And what is Canada quietly doing that’s way more impressive?
[00:38:04] Ian: I mean, when you said I’ve been thinking about Canada, I’m like, “yeah, aren’t we all?”
[00:38:10] Emmett: Yeah, especially lately.
[00:38:17] Ian: I have a couple of questions about like the House of Transit as, you know, as an entity. So like like Streets.mn when it was founded, that was really intentionally like put together as a 501c3 and everything so that it had, you know, like like the people who founded it were thinking about, you know, what’s the longevity going to be like what, you know, when the individuals who started it aren’t around anymore. Is the House of Transit? Did you guys have you guys been thinking about that kind of thing? Or were you just like, let’s get together and make some videos like anybody can come and do it.
[00:38:52] Evan: Honestly, you bring it up is like probably the first time we’ve ever thought about like, oh, like organizing this to a proper thing. No, we’ve really not thought about that at all. This is very much like kind of like, I guess spontaneous is not the word I’d use, but it’s just kind of like a kind of like a momental thing. Like, oh yeah, we were just like, let’s make some videos. Let’s like put our ideas out there and see what happens. We do get revenues from the channel, but we don’t really like split it up amongst the people. We just kind of have it put in our little savings and then we use that for whatever like channel expenses we have sometimes.
[00:39:25] Emmett: So yeah, I appreciate the other members of the channel trusting me with our funds because I did just put it at an old like unused bank account of mine. Haven’t embezzled anything yet. We’ll see how long it takes before people catch on.
[00:39:38] Ian: It would be, you know, if you if you just came onto our podcast and was like, “yeah, this is this here now, is when I’m going to admit to embezzling a bunch of money.” Like that would have been wild.
[00:39:50] Emmett: No, no, no. Yeah, it is. It is funny to be to be making money because that wasn’t the goal. Yeah, I think I think if it ever got to a point where for some reason we weren’t making videos, we actually we have like the other people who have contributed to the channel do have access to the YouTube information. So it’s sort of we have to be careful about that, right, about like who we’re sharing that with. But obviously, I think we if we ever weren’t the ones contributing, which I don’t see happening, but we’ll see what happens. Then, yeah, we definitely if there was interest to keep that going, I think we’d find some way to push that on for now, though. This is our baby. This is our child. This is our our house of transit. So we’re going to keep it going as long as we can.
[00:40:36] Evan: Yeah, this is a like a passion project to the fullest extent. There’s been no like, oh, let’s think about like longevity or like the money incentive. No, it’s just like we like making videos. We like we like learning and discussing like transportation topics. And so this is just like our way of like contributing to that broader discourse.
[00:40:55] Parker: Nice, nice. Just for fun, not for profit.
[00:41:00] Evan: Yeah.
[00:41:02] Ian: Did you guys think about the acronym when you named it The House of Transit?
[00:41:09] Emmett: Yes, regretfully, our high school selves. That was that was the defining feature behind that name, actually.
[00:41:19] Evan: Listen, we were like 14 and 15 years old, right?
[00:41:23] Emmett: We we just recently changed the banner from something that I think was a little bit more unsightly. So, yeah, the rebrand really dropping the T I think was a big step forward for us.
[00:41:38] Ian: When obviously I have, you know, this recording is on my calendar so that I, you know, remembered to be here in the studio to do it. And when my girlfriend saw on my calendar “THOT,” she was like, excuse me, what’s going on? And I was like, yeah, we’re.
[00:41:54] Emmett: Yeah, that’s a tough one to explain.
[00:41:59] Ian: That’s good. No, there’s there’s something really pure about that, honestly.
[00:42:02] Emmett: Like, you know, it’s it’s a map of our growth as a as a community to look back and remember where it all started.
[00:42:14] Evan: We didn’t mean anything bad by the acronym either. We were just thinking it was really funny.
[00:42:19] Emmett: Yeah, I will say going off of that, the one really unfortunate thing and part of the motivation behind maybe changing our name is when you can go into YouTube statistics, obviously, unfortunately, the urbanist space is just like really dominated by white men.
[00:42:36] Ian: Yeah.
[00:42:37] Emmett: But in particular, there were times when I would log in like I’m sure it’s rounding, but like genuinely 100 percent of our viewers were male. And it’s like, wow, that’s that’s severe.
[00:42:48] Ian: That’s pretty dire.
[00:42:49] Emmett: Yeah. We need to find some way which we probably haven’t found yet.
[00:42:55] Ian: I mean, we have to acknowledge that here we are two white men in interviewing two white men about their YouTube channel.
[00:43:02] Emmett: So like, yeah, we’re part of the problem. Right. So what can you do?
[00:43:07] Ian: I think that having I mean, this is something that Streets.mn has struggled with as well of being like a community blog and also like the people who have the time and energy to write about, you know, like a thing that’s not going to make them money is like, yeah, it’s it’s a lot of like well-to-do white people who write for Streets.mn And, you know, that’s like for the last, I don’t know, four or five years, like the organization has had that as a specific goal of like, like, what are the different things that we can do as an organization to increase the diversity of our of our contributor base? So, yeah.
[00:43:51] Evan: There’s just like a lot of like, I think, social like connotations around like this kind of work, especially like transit. And like the train space because like, I don’t know about you guys, but we always had like there’s always the image of like the foamer, which is, you know, like the white guy who like stands by the tracks for like five hours and like gets really excited about all the trains, you know, it’s kind of like what a lot of people understand this kind of community to be, especially if you’re like older, I think. So like I think that kind of stuff is like kept this a very like male enclosed space, unfortunately. I think it was interesting at least something that I noticed was that there are a lot more women when you get into like the professional levels, because we were both at the American Public Transportation’s conference in Chicago a few weekends ago. And there were a lot more women there than I would have expected. And, you know, they were in like, you know, general managerial positions. But like when I met two people from Metra, they were both women. And one of them was in legal and the other was in like community outreach stuff. So it might just be it’s like, you know, this online space more so than just like the professional world, because we’re not really there’s like a bit of distance between those two. It’s just an interesting space to occupy. Like this has like no women whatsoever just in our like little corner of the Internet.
[00:45:11] Parker: Right. And then it also calls into question, if that’s the case, why is there diversity over there and not on the on this other space? Like, what is what is causing that gap?
[00:45:22] Emmett: Yeah, no, it’s a tough question. One of the coolest things I’ve seen is Banks Rail, who’s kind of a smallish, medium sized YouTube channel, a little bigger than us. He’s like probably one of the only black men I’ve seen in transit urbanism YouTube. And he had this initiative or just like this program that he put together himself, as far as I can tell, of inviting these black kids onto his channel, basically to create their own content. And he paid them for it. And it was just this really cool way of being like, you know, I think we’re living proof that anybody can do this, right? You can just like decide that you’re going to create a YouTube channel and it might go somewhere, you know, and that’s that’s really cool. And so I think I don’t know. I don’t know about the audience as much. I think that that would probably help with that, too, of people being able to see people who are representing their own identities in there, but especially for people to be creating this content to be like, yeah, like anybody can do this. It’s it’s just that easy to a certain extent. And yeah, I really I think any way to sort of encourage that would be amazing.
[00:46:32] Ian: The thirty three thousand people who watched the Twin Cities video that you made in like the first weekend, you know, it’s it shows you like Minnesotans have a real hunger for this kind of topic, you know, about our hometown. And it’s I don’t know how many of them are going like going to stick around for other metro areas. But also, like that was kind of part of why I was so excited when when I messaged you guys and you got back to me like literally within hours of like, yeah, yeah, let’s let’s cross post the video on Streets.mn. And I was like, great, awesome. And so, you know, enough people who were watching that video when it was still new also saw like our logo, our link on that video. And, you know, we I mean, the number of new subscribers that we had from that is it sounds ridiculous when when you say it, it’s like, oh, there were I think there were like 70 new subscribers in the first couple of days. But that doubled the number of subscribers that our YouTube channel had. So it’s like, OK, that is the kind of like bump that the channel needs. And then also, hopefully that will help the people who are looking for this kind of Minnesota based urbanist content like, you know, they’re going to then keep seeing it because obviously like it’s not just the videos that I’m making for the channel, like we’re trying to partner with as many other YouTube channels who are making, you know, occasionally making stuff about Minnesota as well.
[00:48:04] Emmett: Yeah. So, yeah, I wish I had known to put in a reference to you guys verbally in the video, because actually an interesting thing that I saw was I mentioned the I-94 Rail Coalition in there, which unfortunately like isn’t a very active group anymore. I think they were really pouncing on the opportunity to sort of influence the study, which at this point maybe it’s sort of on the later end of what can really be done to convince MnDOT to change their ways. But it was really interesting because I’m in the Discord server for that channel or that group, and it was just lighting up with people joining it. And eventually, like one of the moderators like pinged the guys in charge, he’s like, hey, we got a lot of people joining. And then it put up this whole message like, you know, unfortunately, we’re not an active group, but if you want to keep talking about this, go join any of these places. So I think that was that was really awesome because I’ve never gotten to see like firsthand the influence of people wanting to talk about these things based on like a conversation that we’re starting.
[00:49:01] Ian: Nice. Yeah. I mean, even though you didn’t mention Streets.mn like out loud, I think you did have on the screen like an article that you guys had used as part of your research.
[00:49:11] Emmett: Yeah, referenced a lot of articles from you all. So thank you for that. That makes our job easier.
[00:49:17] Ian: And I mean, thanks to the individual contributors who wrote those articles.
[00:49:21] Evan: Yeah, shout out to the people at Streets.mn. You guys are great because I’ve also read your articles in the past as well. Just like learning about the Twin Cities. It’s always great to have like these little like localized, like urbanist publications, because even though blogging isn’t the stuff that it used to be, obviously, it’s like a really great way to just get updates on this kind of stuff. And it’s so much more easier to get like more than like YouTube because the YouTube video is going to be coming out every so once a while. But like you can get blog posts like multiple in a day. It’s much easier that way. Also, I want to loop back to a point you made earlier about like there’s a real craving for like transit content in like Minnesota Twin Cities. I think I’ve noticed this sometimes when looking at our like view counts, like usually videos about Seattle do crazy numbers, like usually way better than any of our stuff in Chicago itself. And I think some of that is like we’ve become like an established channel about Seattle. But part of that is also I think there’s probably a lot more energy, especially considering Link is going through like so much expansion right now. It’s a very like present and hot topic in many like Seattlites’ minds, whereas like our videos about Chicago are kind of like covering topics that are not as like present in like people’s minds as much because like, you know, not every Chicagoan is like “I care about like what’s going on with the L. We need to fire Dorval Carter.” That’s like a very small group of people who will like see our Chicago L video and be like, “that’s true. I agree with this.” So I think there’s definitely like some cities have a lot more like I guess kind of like motion around these topics than others I’ve noticed. And it’s very interesting to watch like which videos we just like blow up out of nowhere and which ones are like just kind of go a little more under the radar.
[00:50:59] Emmett: Yeah, it’s a self-fulfilling prophecy for sure. Just like when when there’s energy and excitement for this stuff, you get more and more of that.
[00:51:06] Ian: And I don’t know if this is also the case in in other metro areas. But like like whenever CityNerd does a video about the Twin Cities, the attitude that I see from a lot of my friends who are sharing the video around is literally just like, wow, somebody noticed us. Somebody’s talking about us. Look at that. Feel so special.
[00:51:26] Emmett: Yeah, I sort of get that. I feel like when I when I see video content about Seattle from other people, my first instinct is like, hey, that’s my territory. But after that, it’s like, wow, like it’s cool. Like that’s I’ve been there. You know, I live there. This is it’s nice to see somebody else’s take about it as usually we’re all in agreement about these things.
[00:51:50] Parker: What have you been doing lately to spark joy? I will say we’re recording this on November 4th, and there’s there’s a lot of good feeling in the air. I first asked this question when we were doing an episode, I think in December and the mood was very different.
[00:52:07] Ian: Oh, yeah, yeah.
[00:52:08] Emmett: Yeah, no, there’s a lot of reasons to be joyful right now. The classic urbanist answer just getting out and exploring the city and biking. I was working around. I fortunately was able to intern in a position doing a lot of complete streets and bike lane work. So that got me really learning a lot more about bikes, which obviously, you know, we have transit in the name, but we love all things urbanism. And so once I was able to get my bike fixed up and suddenly just hit the streets of Chicago with this new lens of like, oh, my God, look at this contraflow lane. It’s incredible. So all of that’s super fun. And then also, I’m starting to write a research paper for kind of the equivalent of my thesis kind of thing. And I’m looking at pedestrianization in Chicago. And so last Sunday, they did the last it’s called Meet Me on Milwaukee, this event where they just shut down a big portion of this huge commercial street there. And you go out and it’s just all these people walking around and what would normally be a car infested street. And it’s just incredible to see how many people are hungering to be able to get out there and see that. And so that was super fun. My mom was in town. We walked up and down Milwaukee Avenue. That’s a great time.
[00:53:21] Evan: I also feel like we can put out hope out there by being ones to talk about this issue. Like, I know sometimes I can feel very like isolating about like topics like this when it comes to like transportation, urbanism, climate change and a whole other like political smorgasbord of stuff. But like knowing that other people are out there and they believe like similar things they agree on your kind of positions is like very like kind of like grounding and like just like hope filling. Like even though nationally it wasn’t looking like that for a while, you know, the stuff kind of like fell by the wayside after 2024 at the national political level. It’s like, well, there’s still people out there trying to do the good work. And like me personally, I’m working at like a like a little advocacy group in a small neighborhood of Chicago trying to like advocate for better Metra service and like map their community out. And it’s like this is the kind of like the very like not glamorous stuff. You know, this isn’t no like red line extension or stuff like that. This is like very like very localized issue. But I will. I feel joy in the fact that I’m going to improve some people’s lives in like a very material way. You know, if they get better transit access to jobs, that’s a huge win for them. If they’re able to like better navigate around your community, that’s a huge win for them, too. You know, it’s not just about like the big overarching picture. It’s also a lot about the little local things that just go unnoticed.
[00:54:44] Parker: I can speak from personal experiences that being involved in those very local, not like grand, you know, state or federal changing type things, but just I want this road to be better. I want this transit part in this one specific area to be better. Does a whole lot to make you feel like you have an impact. And it also is a fantastic way to make friends.
[00:55:05] Ian: Yeah. And that is kind of one of the the challenging thing I feel like for creators who have kind of a national level lens of like, you know, trying to make those connections and help people find like the really local advocacy opportunities that they have. I mean, it’s not impossible, but it’s like it’s something that you really like. You have to be really intentionally seeking out as a creator, you know, to try to like if that’s like an angle that you want to have.
[00:55:39] Emmett: Yeah, I think that is something that we aim to have. We’ve always I mean, I think our attitude to creating content is just make whatever we want. You know, if people want to watch it, fine. If they don’t, they don’t. But I think definitely more recently, it’s like, how can this be an opportunity to really engage with people who are interested in this stuff and all these different cities? And yeah, like if if we can’t give them the answers, hopefully point them to somewhere where they can keep talking about it.
[00:56:03] Evan: Or they’ll come to us with ideas and such as well. Again, we’re also like a big collaborative channel, big, big group kind of vibes. So if people wanted to like come up to us and they think they have like a pretty good idea that’s worth talking about, then who knows? We maybe we’ll be like, yeah, yeah, you should you should do that and we’ll like help you out in some way.
[00:56:23] Parker: Nice. Well, wonderful. Thank you both for being on the podcast. It has been a pleasure.
[00:56:31] Ian: And thank you for joining us for this episode of the Streets.mn Podcast. The show is released under a Creative Commons attribution, non-commercial, non-derivative license. So feel free to republish the episode as long as you are not altering it and you are not profiting from it. The music in this episode is by Erik Brandt and the Urban Hillbilly Quartet. This episode was produced and edited by Parker Seaman, aka Strongthany, with editing assistance and transcription by me, Ian R. Buck. We’re always looking to feature new voices on the Streets.mn Podcast, so if you have ideas for future episodes, drop us a line at [[email protected]]. Streets.mn is a community publication and relies on contributions from audience members like you. If you can make a one time or recurring donation, you can find more information about doing so at [https://streets.mn/donate]. Find other listeners and discuss this episode on your favorite social media platform using the hashtag #StreetsMNPodcast. Until next time, take care.
